No Mulesing, Please
Patrick Gruban, co-founder and co-owner of German organic yarn pioneer Rosy Green Wool talks about mulesing of Merino sheep, and what knitters can do about this
Strickmich!: In Germany, reports about mulesing in Australian Merino sheep are in the news right now: The sheep’s skin around the buttocks is cut off without any painkillers. The practice has been widely criticized for a long time. Are only Merino sheep in Australia affected?
Patrick Gruban: Yes, Merino sheep are bred specifically to yield the maximum amount of fiber, so they have lots of skin and many skin folds. Into those folds, flies can place their eggs and maggots emerge, especially in the buttock area – this is called “flystrike”. Mulesing is not used in other sheep breeds.
Why is it only common in Australia?
The fly species that harms sheep only exists in Australia and New Zealand. Sheep in South Africa and South America won’t be affected. In New Zealand, farmers have made an effort to breed Merino sheep with fewer skin folds, so the problem of flystrike is not as pronounced there. New Zealand has also developed other methods to combat the flies, and last year they passed a law that prohibits mulesing entirely and sanctions it with heavy fines.
What are alternative methods to prevent flystrike?
If the farmer monitors his flock closely and checks on his sheep regularly, he will notice if anything is wrong and can take action. In Australia, flocks tend to be very large, they roam freely, and are often only monitored by helicopter. The farmer usually sees his sheep twice a year for shearing. Instead of cutting off the sheep’s skin, one could simply shear the area around the buttocks several times a year, so it would stay cleaner and attract fewer flies – but that would be a lot of work, and very expensive for Australian farmers, so only very few do it.
Mulesing also won’t prevent the flies from laying their eggs on other parts of the sheep’s body…
No, but if there is a lot of wool growing on the skin, flies won’t find it so easy to reach the skin to lay their eggs. So it’s not such a big problem in other areas.
Would you consider if progress if anesthetics were used during the mulesing surgery?
It’s not clear how much that would help – the sheep would certainly feel pain until the wounds are healed, which can take several weeks. But it would certainly be a step in the right direction, especially as the problem has been known for years. 70% of all mulesing still happens without painkillers – in my view, that’s outrageous, and can only be explained by farmers’ focus on profits and their greediness. The price for Merino fiber has gone up by 50% during the past years, so they would still earn enough if they were to spend a small amount on anesthetics.
The Australian government could simply pass a law that forbids mulesing…
Sure, especially as Australian sheep farmers have been aware of the problem for more than 15 years. In 2004, there was an initiative to get rid of mulesing until 2010, but that date has passed and nothing has happened. It is always hard to change things when it comes to animal welfare – we see that now in Germany, where the government is trying to pass a law against neutering pigs without painkillers. It takes forever to reach a consensus.
So, if I wanted to buy Merino yarn that was made without mulesing, I could just make sure that the fiber comes from South America, South Africa or New Zealand?
Yes, but that can be difficult, as very few brands can give detailed information about the origins of the fiber or even the sheep breed they used. Some just put “wool” on their label and won’t tell you it is Merino that could be affected by mulesing. Sometimes the supply chain is so long and obscure that it is impossible to tell where the fiber came from: The yarn brand buys from the spinning mill, the spinning mill from a fiber wholesaler, the wholesaler from the producer and so forth. With hand dyers who buy their yarn from a yarn wholesaler, there is an additional step involved. The whole chain relies on trust: The yarn brand or dyer says the yarn is mulesing-free, but cannot really prove it. However, 90% of all Merino fiber worldwide is from Australia, so you need additional proof that they are not part of the yarn you are buying. That’s why we decided right from the beginning that we needed the GOTS certificate – Global Organic Textile Standard. We are also aware how hard it is for hand dyers to find certified yarn bases, so we decided to offer our yarn to them, too.
Why are yarn brands so shy about the topic? There are several around that have been using only Merino fiber from South America or South Africa for years…
If you make a statement like “our yarn is mulesing-free” you kind of lock yourself in, and become less flexible in case of a shortage. At Rosy Green Wool, we cannot use other sources for our Merino fiber and have to make long-term contracts with the suppliers from South America, stating how much we will buy in the upcoming years. That’s quite a risk. For us, it’s even harder as we are the only yarn brand in the world that offers only GOTS-certified yarns, so we cannot use cashmere or silk in our yarns as they are very hard to come by in that quality.
Are hand knitters more aware of mulesing than consumers who buy ready-made clothes?
Yes, especially those who are interested in high-quality hand knitting yarns. But according to my estimates, more than 99.5% of all knitting yarns sold in Germany are still not GOTS-certified. A couple of yarn brands might be in the clear without a certificate because they have a short supply chain, or personally know the farmers providing their wool, and offer mulesing-free Merino – but in the end, they lack the transparency that only a label can provide.
Has the attitude of handknitters towards animal welfare changed since you started out with Rosy Green Wool in 2012?
Mulesing as a discussion point comes up roughly every five years, but I think that’s not enough. We often hear from people who say they became aware of the problem through our yarn, and that they decided to pay more attention to whether a yarn is certified or not in the future – that’s a huge compliment for us!
The Global Organic Textile Standard is the strictest label for textiles produced environmentally friendly, socially conscious and animal friendly. If you buy clothes or yarn carrying the GOTS label, you can be sure that…
• the animals were raised according to high welfare standards, no mulesing took place, and no pesticides were used
• that fair working conditions apply, and no child work was involved
• no chemicals that might harm the environment or human health were used
• waste water is professionally treated, energy use is controlled
• no chemical moth-repellants were used.
More on www.global-standard.org
Rosy Green Wool
Was started in 2012 by Rosmary Stegmann and Patrick Gruban in Munich, and launched Germany’s first GOTS-certified machine-washable Merino yarn for hand knitters. Rosy Green Wool is the only yarn brand in the world that offers only GOTS-certified yarns.
These Yarns in Strickmich! Shop are mulesing-free:
Blacker Yarns (Merino from the Falkland Islands plus Shetland wool)
Schoppel (Merino fiber from Patagonia)
Something to Knit With (Highland Wool from Peru + Alpaca)
Rosy Green Wool (GOTS-certified yarns with Merino fiber from Argentina)
Amano (Alpaca yarns)
Cowgirlblues (Merino fiber from South Africa plus Mohair)
Fino by Manos del Uruguay (Merino fiber from South America)
Yummy 2ply and Yowza by Miss Babs (Merino fiber from South Africa)
Yakusi (Yak Fiber plus Silk )
Fotos © Rosy Green Wool